Small-scale fisheries have a fraction of the resources and political access of larger sectors. A former cabinet secretary leading the largest federation risks widening that imbalance  

SCFF and Fish Legal have published a report written by eftec showing how inshore static gear reserves can deliver a double win for Scotland’s environment and economy. The report explores the benthic impacts of trawl and creel fisheries, focusing on Nephrops in the Firth of Clyde, and suggests that a gradual transition expanding creeling to a moderate 30% share in the Clyde could be able to deliver significant reductions in benthic disturbance. 

SCFF has expressed disappointment at Wildlife and Countryside Link’s recent Hidden in the Haul report, arguing that its emphasis on top-down approaches risk undermining the practical, fisher-led mitigations needed to reduce bycatch and entanglement. 

SCFF undertook this survey to improve understanding of interactions between seals and inshore fishing activity, drawing directly on the experiences of fishermen operating in Scotland and across the UK. The survey sought to gather an objective evidence base on the nature, frequency and geographic distribution of seal-fishery interactions, as well as the impacts these interactions may have on fishing operations including catch rates, profitability and safety at sea.

Respondents were also invited to identify areas where practical support or policy intervention may be beneficial. These wider responses are intended to help SCFF identify potential opportunities for future funding, research and policy initiatives that support the long-term sustainability of low-impact inshore fisheries. 

The results presented in the below summary report provide an overview of the experiences and views reported by participating fishermen. They provide valuable insight into the practical challenges faced by fishermen, and highlight areas where further investigation, engagement and support may be warranted.